Caldwell out?

[larrywilkie]

He's probably got until the end of the season now for me. We seem to be exceptionally streaky under him and I don't think I'm ever likely to be a fan of his, but I will enjoy this form while it lasts.

So if we equal or better last seasons finish, you still want him sacked????

 

[Sexton Blake]

At this moment, they are being proven right and fair play, long may this recent form continue and long may the performance aspect of this recent form continue.

I still would say though, if we had fired him after Fleetwood or Bolton, no one now would be clamouring for him to return. In those moments after Fleetwood, if the board had fired him, it would have been completely justified and fair. Now whether this is by design or a fluke, at the moment it is working. At this moment fair play to the board.

But as we know with Caldwell's reign we are really patchy and we have huge parts of being really poor / unable to obtain results and then a month of exceptional. Lets hope this isn't just a month of exceptional followed by another huge poor part.

Let’s not forget there were reasons for that poor form in that on numerous occasions injury prevented him from selecting some his best players. People were also complaining about the quality of his signings so it is also time for him to be given the credit he deserves for the signings he has made and the way they have and are now performing and recognition that they are better quality than has earlier been suggested on here.

 

[mfcrocker]

So if we equal or better last seasons finish, you still want him sacked????

That's not what I said. I've said I won't be calling for his head again until the end of the season (and will judge his performance then)

 

[Matt Russell]

That's not what I said. I've said I won't be calling for his head again until the end of the season (and will judge his performance then)

Not true.
You used the word "probably" which is somewhat different from "won't"

 

[BigBanker]

Caldwell out






on the lash in Wigan tonight. And deservedly so. Hope he can find a decent Northern Soul night in town.

 

[edwin_price]

Caldwell out






on the lash in Wigan tonight. And deservedly so. Hope he can find a decent Northern Soul night in town.

Bit harsh, that.

 

[geoffwp]

Not true.
You used the word "probably" which is somewhat different from "won't"

Probably would be the better word to put I would say as none of us actually know how it will all pan out.

 

[SaintJames]

He's probably got until the end of the season now for me. We seem to be exceptionally streaky under him and I don't think I'm ever likely to be a fan of his, but I will enjoy this form while it lasts.

If you think the wins today and at Barnsley have been streaky or another meaning down to luck then you will never be a happy man. Enjoy the experience some of the football I have seen in the last few weeks has been some of the most enjoyable i have seen in 40 years. If you cant recognise a team playing well from one you claim are just lucky then possibly a trip to specsavers on monday may be needed

 

[edwin_price]

If you think the wins today and at Barnsley have been streaky or another meaning down to luck then you will never be a happy man. Enjoy the experience some of the football I have seen in the last few weeks has been some of the most enjoyable i have seen in 40 years. If you cant recognise a team playing well from one you claim are just lucky then possibly a trip to specsavers on monday may be needed

Not seen today's game, but I can't think of an occasion when an Exeter side have played better than first half at Barnsley, baring in mind quality of opposition. Could've been 3 or 4.

 

[SaintJames]

Not seen today's game, but I can't think of an occasion when an Exeter side have played better than first half at Barnsley, baring in mind quality of opposition. Could've been 3 or 4.

I have seen us play since 1976 and cant remember except possibly Lincoln away in 1990 anything close to Barnsley