tonykellowfan
Active member
I would love to see Reid's goals and win % for us for all of the games he played last season and this season without Stockley.
Mike, it is perfectly correct that RR scored 7 goals in the first 7 league games, but three of those were after Stockley arrived (FGR and Barnet, when he came on as a sub.)!You're wrong again. He scored 7 goals in the first 7 league games. Then Stockley came onto the scene and it all changed. The point is he was doing well until Stockley arrived. Please check your facts first.
The point I am making is not wrong, which is that there was a change in Reid's scoring potential after Stockley arrived, specifically when he started to play in tandem with Stockley and then when he was benched. This is not in any way a criticism of Stockley, who has done very well in the lone striker role, and it also could be argued that Reid should have tried harder to adapt (maybe a bit of ego damage?). As has been mentioned by other posters, relying on one striker to get the goals is a risky business: lets hope and pray he doesn't get injured or that Brunt can make a dramatic and successful return/Mike, it is perfectly correct that RR scored 7 goals in the first 7 league games, but three of those were after Stockley arrived (FGR and Barnet, when he came on as a sub.)!
In any case, I was not commenting on the period before Stockley arrived, just correcting the stats afterwards. The facts post 2 Sept are as I posted. It is you who are wrong.
I dont necessarily disagree with your analysis, but its a different issue from the statistics I reported. Facts are facts, inference is inference, opinions are opinions.The point I am making is not wrong, which is that there was a change in Reid's scoring potential after Stockley arrived, specifically when he started to play in tandem with Stockley and then when he was benched. This is not in any way a criticism of Stockley, who has done very well in the lone striker role, and it also could be argued that Reid should have tried harder to adapt (maybe a bit of ego damage?). As has been mentioned by other posters, relying on one striker to get the goals is a risky business: lets hope and pray he doesn't get injured or that Brunt can make a dramatic and successful return/
My point is correct but I agree it runs parallel to your stats and does not coincide with them.I dont necessarily disagree with your analysis, but its a different issue from the statistics I reported. Facts are facts, inference is inference, opinions are opinions.