No offence taken if tisdale is as a good judge as you say I don't think you will be signing him then. He has not been the same player since he went to america to have his knee sorted out he is a bit like ledley king in that sense where he needs to rest it just to play on a saturday.Gasman, he was just pointing out that Tisdale has a track record of proving fans wrong. That is why he's a manager and we aren't.
No offence against you, I'm sure you (and the other gasheads) are a very objective, it's just I have a feeling Tisdale knows more about what makes a good player than everybody on exeweb and the gas forums. It's no personal slight against your opinion mate, just an honest appraisal of the reality that some people are better at judging footballers than others.