Caldwell out?

[Red Bill]

this needs to be taken down now

I disagree. Whilst I think a change of title to "Caldwell in or out?" might reflect better the balance of opinions currently, this thread still represents a perfectly valid discussion.

 

[Super Leon Braithwaite]

No it needs to remain as if we lose our first 3 games of the new season I'll be changing my vote

Agree and If we go 100 days without a win again at any point next season i'll be changing my vote back to "out".

 

[ramone]

this needs to be taken down now

Ahh the good old freedom of speech police , Next you'll be telling us what we can or can't think ala 1984 !!

 

[citytillidie72]

If I was against a thread, I just wouldn't post on it and let it die a natural death. Some of our fans aren't the brightest.

 

[Boyo]

I don't mind this thread and will continue to read it. What is very evident now of course, is that the poll linked to this thread is totally meaningless. I'd be amazed if 5% of City fans want him to go, let alone the 45% as per the current results on the poll. Even in the darkest moments, towards the end of the winless run, the poll never reflected the opinion of the city fans that I know and chat to. That group is limited to a dozen or so people, but only one or two wanted him gone, whilst the majority felt that sticking by him was the best move. That's not to say they backed him, but that sacking him was the wrong move.

 

[Grecian Max]

the poll never reflected the opinion of the city fans that I know and chat to

Completely different to what I experienced

The poll sat on around 60/40 for a long time, so just a bit over half of the fanbase split on him after the 3/4 month winless run

Sounds about right tbh

 

[SDRighton]

Is the historical data for this poll recorded? Would be interesting to see how it fluctuated through the season.

 

[denzel]

Even in the darkest moments, towards the end of the winless run, the poll never reflected the opinion of the city fans that I know and chat to. That group is limited to a dozen or so people, but only one or two wanted him gone, whilst the majority felt that sticking by him was the best move.

That might be your experience but it's not mine. The majority of my cohort wanted him gone in November / December. Most have changed their mind, but let's not rewrite history.

 

[Bat Fastard]

I don't mind this thread and will continue to read it. What is very evident now of course, is that the poll linked to this thread is totally meaningless. I'd be amazed if 5% of City fans want him to go, let alone the 45% as per the current results on the poll. Even in the darkest moments, towards the end of the winless run, the poll never reflected the opinion of the city fans that I know and chat to. That group is limited to a dozen or so people, but only one or two wanted him gone, whilst the majority felt that sticking by him was the best move. That's not to say they backed him, but that sacking him was the wrong move.

Agree with the above, your experience completely different to mine chap

 

[Grecian Max]

That might be your experience but it's not mine. The majority of my cohort wanted him gone in November / December. Most have changed their mind, but let's not rewrite history.

No, a poll of 378 people is less reliable than Boyo’s Dozen