Player Ratings

[I am The BIGGEST Banker]

Here is my opinion if the ratings for the city players against walsall.
Jones. 7 for shot stopping 3 for distribution
Tully. 7
Taylor. 8
Edwards 7
Duffy 5. He put jones under a bit of pressure with needless backpasses
Friend. 7
Dunne 6
Sercome. 8.5
Harley. 8
Stewart. 8. Until his legs went
Corr. 7
Logon. 6
Big bank. 10. What an atmosphere!!

What are your thoughts!!!

 

[information_ministry]

Jones. 7 for shot stopping 3 for distribution
Tully. 7
Taylor. 8
Edwards 8
Duffy 6. He put jones under a bit of pressure with needless backpasses
Friend. 6
Dunne 6
Sercome. 7
Harley. 5.333
Stewart. 2. for turning up
Corr. 7
Logon. 8
Big bank. 7.
O.G. 8
Doble 2 were they there?
Referee 10 for giving us a penalty that was dodgy
Tis 9 for the negative tactics that actually worked today

 

[sirhc]

Jones 6 Very dodgy kicking

Tully 7.5 Excellent for first 20 (until injury)

Taylor 9 Superb (motm)

Edwards 7 Solid

Duffy 7.5 Solid

Friend 7 Good

Harley 8 Made one, scored one

Sercombe 7

Dunne 7 Decent midfield partnership being generated

Corr 7 Played well

Stewart 5 Out of position

Tisdale 7 Many were calling for changes in the OG (as usual), if they had got back to 2-2 just imagine the critcism he would have got on here

Big Bank 7 (from the OG) Decent, but heard alot better

Subs:

Logan 8 Excellent when he came on

 

[heathy1]

Referee 10!!? that was the only thing he gave us all game!!

 

[Hants_red]

Not bad. Would score Jones less because of hid kicking, and Friend less for general all round ineffectiveness.

 

[heathy1]

Did you see the bobbling on the pitch today? its no wonder 100% of Jonesy's kicks did not go straight and perfect!

 

[older-codger]

Did you see the bobbling on the pitch today? its no wonder 100% of Jonesy's kicks did not go straight and perfect!

It was very bobbly and must have made control very difficult (no that it excused all of his poor kicks though).

As for the OP giving Duffy a 5, you obviously don't watch very closely. Try counting the number of times he makes a covering tackle all across the defence.

 

[wemissmoxey]

Bloody hell,

If we actually play some decent football everyone will get a ten looking at the way others rated todays performances.

For me most players were around the 6 mark.

 

[mole221]

I reckon:
Jones. 6. A few good saves, but not his best performance in the distribution
Tully. 7
Taylor. 8
Edwards 8
Duffy 7
Friend. 7 Showed brief glimpses of quality but still made a few mistakes
Dunne 7
Sercome. 8
Harley. 7. Soom good play, but I just wish he'd shoot every so often
Stewart. 6 Did a couple of useful bits, but got tired, and should have been subbed
Corr. 6
Sub:
Logan. 7 Kept the defence under good pressure and forced them to make mistakes

 

[dommers]

Jones 6
Tully 4
Taylor 5
Edwards 7
Duffy 7
Friend 6
Dunne 4
Sercombe 6
Harley 7
Stewart 6
Corr 6

Logan 7