arthur
Very well known Exeweb poster
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2004
- Messages
- 11,947
I was merely quoting Jinx's phrase. But you knew that!Interesting you seem to think that was Stansfield's best.
I was merely quoting Jinx's phrase. But you knew that!Interesting you seem to think that was Stansfield's best.
and Stanno's further improvement this season may well be a reflection of how Caldwell managed him last season.I was merely quoting Jinx's phrase. But you knew that!
I'm agnostic on Caldwell's contribution to Stansfield's game, but I don't think it's obvious he's helped him a lot. The kids miles off league one level... Struggled to make that impact for stretches last season.and Stanno's further improvement this season may well be a reflection of how Caldwell managed him last season.
Do you mean he is now? But he's playing in the ChampionshipI'm agnostic on Caldwell's contribution to Stansfield's game, but I don't think it's obvious he's helped him a lot. The kids miles off league one level... Struggled to make that impact for stretches last season.
Clearly none of us can scientifically prove it one way or another. All I have is 'evidence' that the public affection shown by Stanno at the last game to Gary was some kind of a thank you to GC. Also that GC stuck with Stanno during the lean spell must have helped Stanno in terms of maintaining his confidence. That's the case for the prosecution M'ludI'm agnostic on Caldwell's contribution to Stansfield's game, but I don't think it's obvious he's helped him a lot. The kids miles off league one level... Struggled to make that impact for stretches last season.
I would argue that he very often made an impact during his barren spell, as his game is not just about scoring.I'm agnostic on Caldwell's contribution to Stansfield's game, but I don't think it's obvious he's helped him a lot. The kids miles off league one level... Struggled to make that impact for stretches last season.
I think Edwin is suggesting that Jay is miles ABOVE League One level but, in his opinion, that wasn't always evident last season.Do you mean he is now? But he's playing in the Championship
I mean he's clearly way too good for league one. I'm just not convinced on it either way... I certainly wouldn't list him as a self-evident GC triumph.Do you mean he is now? But he's playing in the Championship