Manager Thread..Appointments & Dismissals

Colesman Ballz

Well-known Exeweb poster
Joined
Dec 28, 2014
Messages
9,885
I am totally amazed that "Bad Boy" Barton is still clinging on to his job by his finger nails ! :unsure:
 
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
702
Location
Portsmouth
I am totally amazed that "Bad Boy" Barton is still clinging on to his job by his finger nails ! :unsure:
I think the Rovers owner is stuck between a rock and a hard place - largely of this own making. They made a strategic decision when Graham Coughlan left them in L1 to get the wage bill down, reduce cost and slow losses. The idea was to employ a decent coach who would bring youngsters through with a resale value - the previous model appeared to be the owner(s) subsidising losses to keep them in L1. They employed Ben Garner who had a decent reputation working with PL youngsters and from the outside it appears they expected him to jettison the older (and higher earning) pros inherited by previous managers and work with youngsters identified by their DoF/equivalent, Tommy Widdrington. At that point they basically wrote off a promising campaign - I think Coughlan had them in the top 6 in L1 - as the writing was on the wall for many in the squad when the Garner appointment was made. Garner got off to a slow start last season but appeared to start to be turning things around when he was sacked with, I think, them around the bottom third but not in contention for the drop when he went.

What followed was mental. They dropped Garner, appointed Tisdale (I think on the basis he was available and his record with yourselves) and there appears to have been a very quick realisation that Tisdale, Widdrington and their CEO Starnes; who appears to have a mediocre record at best, couldn't work together. That strategy appears to have lasted 18 months as they then appointed Barton and gave him licence to completely overhaul the squad and bring in players who didn't match the strategy they had only signed up to 18 covid-affected months previous.

I've got lots of sympathy with the Rovers support - they're a proper club with a decent identity. The senior management, less so. However, if they sack Barton now, where do they go? Someone like Flynn is available and may be an upgrade on Barton but, at some point, they need to work out what they're trying to achieve and the model they want to use. If they don't get things right very soon could see them becoming another Grimsby, Oldham, etc.
 
Top