England's Ashes Test Team

Jason H

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 1, 2004
Messages
35,407
Location
Hounslow, Middlesex
Dar used to be a very good umpire. Seems to have lost it a bit.

Gaffney made a howler later by all accounts.

Thank goodness for DRS.
Gaffney's one (I assume this is the LBW that was successfully overturned) didn't sound like a howler, but Dar's one sounded like it was going to hit middle stump.
 

RedPaul

Active member
Joined
Apr 23, 2004
Messages
2,384
Location
Woking
Gaffney's one (I assume this is the LBW that was successfully overturned) didn't sound like a howler, but Dar's one sounded like it was going to hit middle stump.
Gaffney's one (Wade) pitched about 2 inches outside leg. Would have knocked all 3 out and Australia almost didn't review. Dar's was a shocker. Broad basically didn't appeal and just celebrated as it was as obviously out as if it had been nicked straight to 2nd slip. It would have hit the middle of middle stump, having pitched in line and hit in line.
 

Alistair20000

Very well known Exeweb poster
Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
30,554
Location
Hunkered down
Gaffney's one (Wade) pitched about 2 inches outside leg. Would have knocked all 3 out and Australia almost didn't review. Dar's was a shocker. Broad basically didn't appeal and just celebrated as it was as obviously out as if it had been nicked straight to 2nd slip. It would have hit the middle of middle stump, having pitched in line and hit in line.
Cricinfo commentary stated that the Wade LBW might have missed off stump as well as pitching clearly outside leg stump. Umps usually get the ones that pitch outside leg correct. Apologies to Gaffers if it was not a howler.
 

Rosencrantz

Active member
Joined
Jul 12, 2019
Messages
1,673
Location
Tiverton
Sounds like an absolute stinker of a decision by Dar - as Aggers said, that is what DRS is for.
You can only think Dar thought there might have been an inside edge. Only seen brief replay so can't see if it clipped the back pad as well which could have produced two noises.
 
Top