Cambridge United v Exeter City FA Cup 2nd Round Match Day Thread

andrew p long

Well-known Exeweb poster
Joined
Jan 6, 2006
Messages
9,635
Location
Hagley, Stourbridge
My conclusion is that he either did not know the laws of the game, or that he panicked under pressure from the Cambridge crowd and players, and capitulated. Either way it is a depressing example of the weakness we see regularly from officials. It is why players from every team pressurise referees: it works. You get decisions overturned in your favour as a result.
sadly this is so true. We know how it all works. Once the referee has given an important decision for the away side he doesn't want stick from the home fans if they lose, so he looks for a decision to 'even things up'. Right from the penalty I knew the ref would make a big call against us at some stage. Frankly I suspected that would be sending off Ray due to the running battle he was having with Ironside.

So it makes sense for teams to make the referee think that he's got a decision wrong by surrounding him. It now makes sense, in terms of winning games, for every club's players to do what the Cambridge players did...but that is so bad for the game.

Oh ...and consistency. Matt Taylor booked for dissent. Law 12 cautions (bookings) for any 'dissent by word or action' So why weren't the Cambridge players complaining about the linesman's decision booked? We all know why - its because it is a law that weak officials and officialdom have consistently failed to enforce, so much so that it has fallen into disrespect.

(to repeat what my referee instructor Bob Bassindale said when I was qualifying as a referee 30+ years ago - ' a player comes chasing after me only for one of two things - a yellow card or a red card')
 

SEA Grecian

Active member
Joined
Oct 14, 2018
Messages
4,133
sadly this is so true. We know how it all works. Once the referee has given an important decision for the away side he doesn't want stick from the home fans if they lose, so he looks for a decision to 'even things up'. Right from the penalty I knew the ref would make a big call against us at some stage. Frankly I suspected that would be sending off Ray due to the running battle he was having with Ironside.

So it makes sense for teams to make the referee think that he's got a decision wrong by surrounding him. It now makes sense, in terms of winning games, for every club's players to do what the Cambridge players did...but that is so bad for the game.

Oh ...and consistency. Matt Taylor booked for dissent. Law 12 cautions (bookings) for any 'dissent by word or action' So why weren't the Cambridge players complaining about the linesman's decision booked? We all know why - its because it is a law that weak officials and officialdom have consistently failed to enforce, so much so that it has fallen into disrespect.

(to repeat what my referee instructor Bob Bassindale said when I was qualifying as a referee 30+ years ago - ' a player comes chasing after me only for one of two things - a yellow card or a red card')
There was an interesting and perhaps unintentionally honest tweet after the game from the Cambridge keeper. I know I'll get accused of being naive and idealistic but, personally, I'm quite glad the City players are not willing to win at any cost.

 

Devonbean

Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
94
Class 1 FA Referee 1971 (retired) Byl. I still know when I see a player possibly getting clipped going down late. Some refs would have given that, a lot wouldnt. We were lucky to get that penalty, but it didnt matter in the end, did it?
Well, you certainly refereed an Exeter Sunday League division 1 game on 09.01.72 Stoke Hill v Crescent !
 

Colesman Ballz

Very well known Exeweb poster
Joined
Dec 28, 2014
Messages
10,435
He was probably but not given so need to move on. I just hope we haven't got any fines in place for being booked for dissent as it's a very poor example from our manager.
Oh come down off your high horse ! As a manager you are demonstrating your support for your players, and a damned sight more effectively than simply wearing a cravat ! :p
 

CC

Active member
Joined
Apr 2, 2004
Messages
2,995
Location
Hope
Cambridge drawn away at Newcastle in the 3rd round...
 
Top